[{"id":428585484537,"handle":"all","title":"ALL","updated_at":"2025-07-03T14:45:28-04:00","body_html":"","published_at":"2024-08-16T07:53:21-04:00","sort_order":"best-selling","template_suffix":"","disjunctive":false,"rules":[{"column":"type","relation":"not_equals","condition":"giftit"},{"column":"vendor","relation":"not_contains","condition":"Onward"}],"published_scope":"web"},{"id":423954907385,"handle":"decades-before-1919-retro-candy","title":"Before 1919 Retro Candy","updated_at":"2025-07-03T12:50:30-04:00","body_html":"","published_at":"2024-05-29T03:27:01-04:00","sort_order":"best-selling","template_suffix":"","disjunctive":false,"rules":[{"column":"tag","relation":"equals","condition":"Decades\/Before 1919 Retro Candy"}],"published_scope":"web","image":{"created_at":"2024-11-07T04:17:45-05:00","alt":"Before 1919 Retro Candy - CandyFavorites","width":430,"height":516,"src":"\/\/www.candyfavorites.com\/cdn\/shop\/collections\/Before_1919_Retro_Candy_-_CandyFavorites-5193406.jpg?v=1730971065"}},{"id":423953727737,"handle":"root-category-all-candy-fun-size-candy","title":"Fun Size Candy","updated_at":"2025-07-03T12:40:46-04:00","body_html":"","published_at":"2024-05-29T03:26:55-04:00","sort_order":"best-selling","template_suffix":"","disjunctive":false,"rules":[{"column":"tag","relation":"equals","condition":"All Candy\/Fun Size Candy"}],"published_scope":"web","image":{"created_at":"2024-12-04T14:06:08-05:00","alt":null,"width":675,"height":420,"src":"\/\/www.candyfavorites.com\/cdn\/shop\/collections\/Mars_Chocolate_Favorites_Fun_Size_Mix_-_CandyFavorites-3981924.jpg?v=1733339168"}},{"id":423953826041,"handle":"root-category-all-candy-gluten-free-candy","title":"Gluten Free Candy","updated_at":"2025-07-02T20:55:17-04:00","body_html":"","published_at":"2024-05-29T03:26:56-04:00","sort_order":"best-selling","template_suffix":"","disjunctive":false,"rules":[{"column":"tag","relation":"equals","condition":"All Candy\/Gluten Free Candy"}],"published_scope":"web","image":{"created_at":"2024-12-04T13:52:11-05:00","alt":null,"width":1200,"height":960,"src":"\/\/www.candyfavorites.com\/cdn\/shop\/collections\/Dum_Dums_Lollipops_Bulk_-_CandyFavorites-3970088.jpg?v=1733338331"}},{"id":423971127545,"handle":"root-category-holiday-candy-halloween-candy","title":"Halloween Candy","updated_at":"2025-07-03T12:40:46-04:00","body_html":"","published_at":"2024-05-29T03:29:21-04:00","sort_order":"best-selling","template_suffix":"","disjunctive":false,"rules":[{"column":"tag","relation":"equals","condition":"Holiday Candy\/Halloween Candy"}],"published_scope":"web","image":{"created_at":"2024-12-04T14:05:26-05:00","alt":null,"width":430,"height":380,"src":"\/\/www.candyfavorites.com\/cdn\/shop\/collections\/HolidayPage_Banner_Halloween_mobile.jpg?v=1733339127"}},{"id":423967719673,"handle":"root-category-brands-judson-atkinson-candies","title":"Judson Atkinson Candies","updated_at":"2025-07-03T01:50:11-04:00","body_html":"","published_at":"2024-05-29T03:28:49-04:00","sort_order":"best-selling","template_suffix":"","disjunctive":false,"rules":[{"column":"tag","relation":"equals","condition":"Brands \/Judson Atkinson Candies"}],"published_scope":"web","image":{"created_at":"2024-12-04T13:55:37-05:00","alt":null,"width":1200,"height":960,"src":"\/\/www.candyfavorites.com\/cdn\/shop\/collections\/Sour_Balls_-_CandyFavorites-3990678.jpg?v=1733338538"}},{"id":423964705017,"handle":"root-category-candy-types-retro-favorites","title":"Retro Favorites","updated_at":"2025-07-02T15:25:25-04:00","body_html":"","published_at":"2024-07-18T02:54:00-04:00","sort_order":"best-selling","template_suffix":"","disjunctive":false,"rules":[{"column":"tag","relation":"equals","condition":"Candy Types\/Retro Favorites"}],"published_scope":"web","image":{"created_at":"2024-12-10T12:46:01-05:00","alt":null,"width":527,"height":425,"src":"\/\/www.candyfavorites.com\/cdn\/shop\/collections\/Marpro_Yum_-_Yum_Marshmallow_Candy_Cones_-_CandyFavorites-3981868.jpg?v=1733852762"}},{"id":423956644089,"handle":"root-category-color-yellow-candy","title":"Yellow Candy","updated_at":"2025-07-03T09:00:29-04:00","body_html":"","published_at":"2024-05-29T03:27:09-04:00","sort_order":"best-selling","template_suffix":"","disjunctive":false,"rules":[{"column":"tag","relation":"equals","condition":"Color\/Yellow Candy"}],"published_scope":"web","image":{"created_at":"2024-12-04T14:08:56-05:00","alt":null,"width":664,"height":425,"src":"\/\/www.candyfavorites.com\/cdn\/shop\/collections\/Yellow_Lemon_Rock_Candy_Strings_-_CandyFavorites-3994987.jpg?v=1733339336"}}]
["All Candy\/Fun Size Candy","All Candy\/Gluten Free Candy","All Candy\/Vegan Candy","all snacks","Before 1919 Retro Candy","Brands \/Judson Atkinson Candies","Candy Types\/Retro Favorites","catalog_search","Color\/Yellow Candy","Decades\/Before 1919 Retro Candy","Fun Size Candy","Gluten Free Candy","Halloween Candy","Holiday Candy\/Halloween Candy","Judson Atkinson Candies","NON SUPPLY GIFT SNACKS","Recommended products (Seguno)","Retro Candy","Retro Favorites","Vegan Candy","Yellow Candy"]

This store requires javascript to be enabled for some features to work correctly.

FREE SHIPPING on orders over $149.95!
Choose Checkout+ Package Protection for 100% Order Satisfaction & 5% Cash Back!
  • All Candy
    • ALL CANDY
    • Boxed Chocolates
    • Bulk Candy
    • Candy Closeout Sales
    • Candy Bars
    • Candy Coins
    • CandyFavorites Bags
    • Chewing Gum
    • Cough Drops
    • Eda's Sugarfree Candy
    • Edible Insects
    • Fudge
    • Fun Size Candy
    • Gummi Candies
    • Jelly Belly Candy
    • Kosher Candy
    • Licorice Candy
    • Lollipops
    • Marshmallow Peeps
    • Mints
    • Old Fashion Candy Sticks
    • New Candy
    • Novelty Candy
    • Pez Dispensers
    • Pop Rocks
    • Potato Chips
    • Satellite Wafers
    • Snack Food
    • Snyder of Berlin
    • Sports Candy
    • Sugar Free
    • Taffy
    • Theater Size Candy
    • Variety Packs
    • Wax Candy
  • Brands
    • ALL BRANDS
    • Arnold's Candies
    • Annabelle Candy Company
    • Brach's Candy Company
    • Boyer Candy
    • CeDe Candy Company
    • Claeys Candy
    • C. Howards Company
    • Dubble Bubble
    • Farley & Sathers
    • Ferrara Pan
    • Goetzes Candy
    • Haribo
    • Hershey Chocolates
    • Herr's
    • Jelly Belly Confections
    • Jolly Ranchers
    • Just Born
    • M&M USA
    • Mike and Ikes
    • Pez Candy Incorporated
    • Primrose Candy Company
    • Palmers Chocolate
    • Shuster Company
    • The Wrigley Company
    • Tootsie Roll Industries
    • Toxic Waste Candy
    • Trolli Candy
    • Willy Wonka Candies
  • Color
    • ALL COLORS
    • Blue Candy
    • Brown Candy
    • Glossy Candy
    • Gold Candy
    • Green Candy
    • Lime Candy
    • Orange Candy
    • Pastel Candy
    • Pink Candy
    • Purple Candy
    • Rainbow Candy
    • Red Candy
    • Shiny Wrapped Candy
    • Shimmer Candy
    • Silver Candy
    • Tan Candy
    • White Candy
    • Yellow Candy
  • Decades
    • ALL DECADES
    • Before 1919 Retro Candy
    • 1920's Retro Candy
    • 1930's Retro Candy
    • 1940's Retro Candy
    • 1950's Retro Candy
    • 1960's Retro Candy
    • 1970's Retro Candy
    • 1980's Retro Candy
    • 1990's Retro Candy
    • Retro Candy Gift Boxes
  • Flavors
    • ALL FLAVORS
    • Almond Candy
    • Anise Candy
    • Apple Candy
    • Bacon Flavored Candy
    • Banana Candy
    • Black Licorice
    • Blueberry Candy
    • Blue Raspberry Candy
    • Butterscotch Candy
    • Caramels
    • Caramel Apple Candy
    • Cocktail Classics
    • Champagne Candy
    • Cherry Candy
    • Cinnamon Candy
    • Coffee Candy
    • Cotton Candy
    • Dark Chocolate
    • Doughnut
    • Grape Candy
    • Honey Candy
    • Lemon Candy
    • Malted Milk Balls and more!
    • Nougat
    • Orange Candy
    • Peach Candy
    • Peanut Butter Candy
    • Peppermint Candy
    • Pickle Candy
    • Pineapple Candy
    • Raisin Candy
    • Raspberry Candy
    • Red Licorice
    • Root Beer Flavored Candy
    • Sour Candy
    • Spearmint Candy
    • Strawberry Candy
    • Toffee Candy
    • Tropical Fruit Candy
    • Unusual Candy Flavors
    • Vanilla Candy
    • Watermelon
    • Wintergreen Candy
  • Gifts
    • ALL GIFTS
    • Gift Certificates
    • Nostalgic Candy Jars
    • Chocolate Covered Cookies
    • Chocolate Bark Gift Boxes
    • Cookie Gift Boxes
    • Fudge Gift Boxes
    • Doll Houses
    • Gift Tins
    • Gift Tubs
    • Golf Related Gifts
    • Jelly Belly Gift Boxes
    • Luxury Gift Baskets
    • Specialty Cookies
    • Specialty Chocolates
    • Medical Gifts
    • More Sweet Gifts
    • Candy of the Month Club
    • Tool Boxes
  • Types
    • ALL TYPES
    • Animals
    • Animated Characters
    • Anniversary
    • Bears
    • Body Parts
    • Candy Jewelry
    • Cars and Trucks
    • Candy Coins
    • Cookie Gift Containers
    • Disney Characters
    • Extra Large Candy
    • Foil Wrapped Candy
    • Food Related Candy
    • Gifts
    • Hearts
    • Gone Fishing
    • Liquid & Spray Candy
    • Non Perishable Parade Candy
    • Party Favors
    • Sports Candy
    • Wax Candy
  • Holiday
    • ALL HOLIDAYS
    • Halloween Candy
    • Christmas Candy
    • Easter Candy
    • Valentine’s Day Candy
    • Mother's Day
    • Patriotic Candy
  • Plan Your Event
  • Australia (AUD $)
  • Canada (CAD $)
  • New Zealand (NZD $)
  • United Kingdom (GBP £)
  • United States (USD $)
  • Log in
CandyFavorites
  • Australia (AUD $)
  • Canada (CAD $)
  • New Zealand (NZD $)
  • United Kingdom (GBP £)
  • United States (USD $)
(0)
  • All Candy
    • ALL CANDY

    • Boxed Chocolates

    • Bulk Candy

    • Candy Closeout Sales

    • Candy Bars

    • Candy Coins

    • CandyFavorites Bags

    • Chewing Gum

    • Cough Drops

    • Eda's Sugarfree Candy

    • Edible Insects

    • Fudge

    • Fun Size Candy

    • Gummi Candies

    • Jelly Belly Candy

    • Kosher Candy

    • Licorice Candy

    • Lollipops

    • Marshmallow Peeps

    • Mints

    • Old Fashion Candy Sticks

    • New Candy

    • Novelty Candy

    • Pez Dispensers

    • Pop Rocks

    • Potato Chips

    • Satellite Wafers

    • Snack Food

    • Snyder of Berlin

    • Sports Candy

    • Sugar Free

    • Taffy

    • Theater Size Candy

    • Variety Packs

    • Wax Candy

  • Brands
    • ALL BRANDS

    • Arnold's Candies

    • Annabelle Candy Company

    • Brach's Candy Company

    • Boyer Candy

    • CeDe Candy Company

    • Claeys Candy

    • C. Howards Company

    • Dubble Bubble

    • Farley & Sathers

    • Ferrara Pan

    • Goetzes Candy

    • Haribo

    • Hershey Chocolates

    • Herr's

    • Jelly Belly Confections

    • Jolly Ranchers

    • Just Born

    • M&M USA

    • Mike and Ikes

    • Pez Candy Incorporated

    • Primrose Candy Company

    • Palmers Chocolate

    • Shuster Company

    • The Wrigley Company

    • Tootsie Roll Industries

    • Toxic Waste Candy

    • Trolli Candy

    • Willy Wonka Candies

  • Color
    • ALL COLORS

    • Blue Candy

    • Brown Candy

    • Glossy Candy

    • Gold Candy

    • Green Candy

    • Lime Candy

    • Orange Candy

    • Pastel Candy

    • Pink Candy

    • Purple Candy

    • Rainbow Candy

    • Red Candy

    • Shiny Wrapped Candy

    • Shimmer Candy

    • Silver Candy

    • Tan Candy

    • White Candy

    • Yellow Candy

  • Decades
    • ALL DECADES

    • Before 1919 Retro Candy

    • 1920's Retro Candy

    • 1930's Retro Candy

    • 1940's Retro Candy

    • 1950's Retro Candy

    • 1960's Retro Candy

    • 1970's Retro Candy

    • 1980's Retro Candy

    • 1990's Retro Candy

    • Retro Candy Gift Boxes

  • Flavors
    • ALL FLAVORS

    • Almond Candy

    • Anise Candy

    • Apple Candy

    • Bacon Flavored Candy

    • Banana Candy

    • Black Licorice

    • Blueberry Candy

    • Blue Raspberry Candy

    • Butterscotch Candy

    • Caramels

    • Caramel Apple Candy

    • Cocktail Classics

    • Champagne Candy

    • Cherry Candy

    • Cinnamon Candy

    • Coffee Candy

    • Cotton Candy

    • Dark Chocolate

    • Doughnut

    • Grape Candy

    • Honey Candy

    • Lemon Candy

    • Malted Milk Balls and more!

    • Nougat

    • Orange Candy

    • Peach Candy

    • Peanut Butter Candy

    • Peppermint Candy

    • Pickle Candy

    • Pineapple Candy

    • Raisin Candy

    • Raspberry Candy

    • Red Licorice

    • Root Beer Flavored Candy

    • Sour Candy

    • Spearmint Candy

    • Strawberry Candy

    • Toffee Candy

    • Tropical Fruit Candy

    • Unusual Candy Flavors

    • Vanilla Candy

    • Watermelon

    • Wintergreen Candy

  • Gifts
    • ALL GIFTS

    • Gift Certificates

    • Nostalgic Candy Jars

    • Chocolate Covered Cookies

    • Chocolate Bark Gift Boxes

    • Cookie Gift Boxes

    • Fudge Gift Boxes

    • Doll Houses

    • Gift Tins

    • Gift Tubs

    • Golf Related Gifts

    • Jelly Belly Gift Boxes

    • Luxury Gift Baskets

    • Specialty Cookies

    • Specialty Chocolates

    • Medical Gifts

    • More Sweet Gifts

    • Candy of the Month Club

    • Tool Boxes

  • Types
    • ALL TYPES

    • Animals

    • Animated Characters

    • Anniversary

    • Bears

    • Body Parts

    • Candy Jewelry

    • Cars and Trucks

    • Candy Coins

    • Cookie Gift Containers

    • Disney Characters

    • Extra Large Candy

    • Foil Wrapped Candy

    • Food Related Candy

    • Gifts

    • Hearts

    • Gone Fishing

    • Liquid & Spray Candy

    • Non Perishable Parade Candy

    • Party Favors

    • Sports Candy

    • Wax Candy

  • Holiday
    • ALL HOLIDAYS

    • Halloween Candy

    • Christmas Candy

    • Easter Candy

    • Valentine’s Day Candy

    • Mother's Day

    • Patriotic Candy

  • Plan Your Event
CandyFavorites
0 Cart
Home / Before 1919 Retro Candy / Mary Jane Nostalgic Candy Jar
Mary Jane Nostalgic Candy Jar - CandyFavorites
Mary Jane Nostalgic Candy Jar - CandyFavorites

                      
                        Mary Jane Nostalgic Candy Jar - CandyFavorites

                      
                        Mary Jane Nostalgic Candy Jar - CandyFavorites
Home / Before 1919 Retro Candy / Mary Jane Nostalgic Candy Jar

Mary Jane Nostalgic Candy Jar - 160 / Jar

Regular price $27.57
Item#: 5359
7 reviews
Ask A Question
  • Default Title
All available inventory for Mary Jane Nostalgic Candy Jar has been added to the cart.
Details

Did you know that rumor has it that Mary Janes were originally created in Paul Revere's old house in Boston?  These delightful taffy candies were one of the oldest American candies until 2018 when NECCO closed it's the door.  Rest assured, they were gone but not forgotten.

As candy lovers around the globe lamented the loss of their favorite Molasses and Peanut Butter taffy, the good folks at Atkinson Candy Co. purchased the formula with the hopes of returning them.

The shape is slightly different but the taste remains as delicious as ever! 

  • 160 ct.
  • Net Weight 20.4 oz.
  • OU Dairy Kosher Certified
  • Made with Real Molasses and Peanut Butter
  • Look below to see former NECCO products that are, once again, being produced.



Protect Your Candy

RUSH PRIORITY Order Processing - CandyFavorites
RUSH PRIORITY Order Processing - CandyFavorites
RUSH Order Processing 
Regular price $5.00
$5.00
(4.2)
Ice Packs - CandyFavorites
Ice Packs - CandyFavorites
Reusable Ice Packs - 1 Unit
Regular price $2.00
$2.00
(4.4)
Hot Weather and Fragile Protection Package - CandyFavorites
Hot Weather and Fragile Protection Package - CandyFavorites
Hot Weather and Fragile Protection Package  - 1 Unit
Regular price $7.00
$7.00
(4.3)

Customer Reviews

Based on 7 reviews
Write a review
57%
(4)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
43%
(3)
N
Nicholas Freitas
Maey Jane

They just isn't the same. The taste, looks, shape, even the color of the wrapping. Sounds like, aw not like it used to be.

Thank you for taking the time to leave a review for our Mary Jane Nostalgic Candy Jar. We understand that the candies taste differently than you may recall. However, we are grateful to be able to offer a classic American candy that has stood the test of time, especially when so many others have disappeared. We value your feedback and will continue to strive to provide the best nostalgic candy experience for our customers!

M
Mark M.
Horrible

Mary Janes should be tender and chewy. These were hard a brittle. When I bite into them the "shatter". Will not buy them again

G
Guest
Mary Jane

Not so good. Either recipe changed or maybe your stock is old?

D
Deanndra W.
Finally

This candy had been out of sales every where for over a year. It is my husband's favorite and I am so glad we found it with this company. They are reliable and helpful.

S
Shelby Chesebro
Worst Candy Ever!

Always the WORST candy given at Halloween and awful flavor. No thanks! Please do not give this candy at Halloween or EVER!

12

EVERY THING WONDERFUL...FRESH ALWAYS, DELIVER

Everything Wonderful...Fresh always, Deliver Quick. The only think was the order was large & in one bag would have liked in two bags. Recommend to everyone...Thank you Always

Laura W.

Sign Up For The Newsletter

Well send you all the latest scoops, including bulk candy coupons, deals and new products.

America's Oldest Wholesale Candy Company

412-678-8851

support@candyfavorites.com

Our Story
  • About Us
  • Early Years
  • Middle Years
  • Future of Candy
  • In The News
Catalogs
  • Bag Candy
  • Easter Catalog
  • Master Candy List
  • New Candy
  • Valentine's Catalog
Sweet Links
  • Bulk Candy
  • Candy Bars
  • Candy Closeout Sales
  • Gift Certificates
  • Wholesale
Service
  • Contact Us
  • Free Shipping
  • Hot Weather FAQs
  • Return Policy
  • Sweet Reviews
Education
  • Candy University
  • Candy in Pop Culture
  • Candy Timeline
  • Discontinued Candies
  • Visual History of Candy
  • Amazon
  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Diners Club
  • Discover
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • Venmo
  • Visa
  • copy_logo

    2008 - 2025  Selavy Ltd. dba CandyFavorites.com

Kristen w
Mild and buttery

Great mild mint taste. Melts in your mouth. Nice size too.

Arnold's Candies Butter Mints
Mark Degironne
I Snaps by the POUND!!!

I saw I could order Snaps after a lifetime drought. I order 6#,s, and ate em all. I saw a problem forming so I ordered 9# of Snaps in 12 oz packs. Still . I wanted sealed Snaps for the long haul. So I ordered another 6# bag … and ate it. The pandemic hits and I salivate over my sealed 12 oz bags. Then I ate em. A year later I found Snpas online. The were not cheap. I bought 4 12 oz bags. Opened the last one yesterday.

Original Formula SNAPS Classic Chewy Candy 12 Ounce Bags 3 Pack
Diane Dyer

I was very grateful for the rush order !
Also the person who helped was just fantastic took great care of my order!

My Sunday school kids will enjoy making their turkey cupcakes with the candy corn.
Thank you 😊
Happy Thanksgiving 🦃🍁

Candy Corn Bulk
Crystal W.
Perfect!!

Couldn’t find these gems in any local store to me so I ordered 5 pounds they were fresh, taste was perfect and they arrived a day early!!!

Halloween Orange and Black Spice Drops
Matt Panush
Perfect amount!!

With decent weather on Halloween, wanted to make sure I had plenty of candy to give away. Delivery was on time and kept me out of the stores buying old candy that had been on the shelves since Labor Day.

Assorted Mini Chocolate Bulk Candy Mix
★ Reviews

Let customers speak for us

12451 reviews
Write a review
81%
(10097)
5%
(635)
3%
(422)
3%
(322)
8%
(976)
1849
M
Assorted Fruit Jelly Slices
Mark
Happy Snacking Time

A fun treat to make you smile.

D
M&M's ® Milk Chocolate Candies 62 oz. Jar
Dave
Very tasty and very chocolate tasting

Very tasty and very chocolate tasting.

T
Clark Bars Milk Chocolate
THOMAS
Melted, but still delicious

The Clark Bars were great, but melted. Only one ice pack was in the shipping box, and the candy melted in the wrappers. A few hours in the frig fixed it up. The candy bars were a delicious lump

A
Fifth Avenue
Anonymous
Old time candy

Old time candy. Excellent

E
Pink Wintergreen Lozenges
Elizabeth
Just like the ones I had as a

Just like the ones I had as a child!!

123

      Free

      Powered by GiftIt

      {"themeColor":"#574CD5","iconColor":"#574CD5","showLogo":true,"topBottomPosition":10,"rightLeftPosition":10,"iconSize":"small","iconCustomSize":64,"position":"middle-right"}